Thank you for helping us by reporting bad content.
These nyx lip liners are great! i honestly dont have one bad thing to say about them. They glide on smooth, have a great color selection and are only $3.50! The colors i have which are shown in the pictures are 839 Dolly Pink and 840 Rose. I have once mac lip liner and i would say that they work exactly the same! Dont waste your money on the high end ones!!
Available here: http://www.nyxcosmetics.com/p-117-slim-lip-pencil.aspx
image is my own