Thank you for helping us by reporting bad content.
The NYX lip liners are by far the best lip liners I have ever used. They are incredible and very inexpensive. I don`t usually wear them on their own (although you can) but they work well under any lipstick. I buy them at Ulta, and they are around $3.50 but NYX often has BOGO 50% off sales.
Have you ever tried the NYX lip liners?