Thank you for helping us by reporting bad content.
I`ve tried many black khol eye liners and I think this Milani LIQUIF`EYE pencil in 01 Black tops them all. You can find them at drugstore, Walmart, Target for about $8. This black color is usually always sold out so if you can get your hands on one, then I highly recommend it.
Ive tried the Urban Decay 24/7, MAC Smolder, Prestige, Loreal Carbon Black, etc but they all smudge and the black color doesnt always show black/dark enough. This Milani one doesnt smudge when its on my waterline. Since its moist there, other liners always move, fade or smudge. This one stays put and doesnt smear. I dont get "raccoon eyes". Also, the black color is super dark (as u can see from the swatch. Its opaque, pigmented, and dark!! The texture is SOOOOOO creamy and soft. It even glides on like a gel liner. The packaging says "liquid-like eye pencil". Other khol pencils tug at my waterline/skin but this one is so smooth. The lasting power is as good as it can be for a pencil liner. Its usually sold out at stores for a reason... because its awesome =). I even pick up back-ups whenever I see it around. I only use this pencil for the waterline area. I dont use it on my lids and smoke it out. In order to remove it easily, you would need an oil based makeup remover.