Thank you for helping us by reporting bad content.
Yesterday I picked up some new E.L.F. items, and today I got around to trying some out, and I realized as soon as I started applying - that I had accidentally found a dupe! The dupe is for my favorite MAC Cremesheen Lipstick in "Creme Cup". The dupe I found for it is E.L.F. Studio Matte Lip Color in "Natural".
Even though the lipstick is creamy with a little bit of shine, the E.L.F. Matte Lip Colors also apply quite creamy and before dying have a bit of shine. In the tubes and swatched, the E.L.F. one looks a tad darker, but on the lips they look basically identical! Also, both are equally pigmented. So, other than the overall finish (being that the "Creme Cup" is only a little bit shiny), I would think it safe to say it`s a pretty good dupe! xox
MAC Lipstick: $14
E.L.F. Studio Matte Lip Color: $3
*Photos are MINE.