Thank you for helping us by reporting bad content.
I`d like to start off by saying that when it comes to liquid liners I am very picky! The first time I applies this liner I thought I wasn`t going to like it because it went on sheer and I had to apply two layers. It`s turns out I didn`t shake the bottle. I did so for my second eye and the color was as black as can be. It was beautiful! This formula is thin (like most liquid liners) and dries to a matte which I love. The applicator is a pointy felt tip which I prefer as well. I did not have any allergic reactions or smudging issues. I actually really like this product and have been using it every time I want a bold liner look.