Thank you for helping us by reporting bad content.
I hold a special place for MAC Club in my heart because it was one of my first MAC eye shadows, ever. A couple days I did a review for the Maybelline LE Eyestudio in Olive Martini, the third color really reminded me of MAC Club and I wanted to do a comparison myself. I also took the time to swatch the definer on the left side from the Comfort Zone Palette from Wet n Wild, since it reminds me of MAC Club as well.
Left to Right: Wet n Wild Comfort Zone Definer, MAC Club, Maybelline Eyestudio in Olive Martini
MAC Club seems to be a slightly more brown compared to the two, although in the pan the three seem to be pretty similar. Wet n Wild and Maybelline seem to be almost exact dupes of each other, with exception to Maybelline having a touch more glitter.
Either way, all three of these colors are very pigmented, creamy, and a dream to blend. So if you don`t need an exact dupe, I`d say the drugstore version is a great alternative. :)
Source link: http://melliecay.blogspot.com