Thank you for helping us by reporting bad content.
These are my new favorite eyeliners! This comes as a set with 8 pencils (colors below) and a two-size sharpener. I got it at Sephora for $34 (on sale). If you ask me, it is a great value! Each pencil has a smudge thing on the other end and a cap (stays clean and the rest of your bag does too).
These are very creamy and glide right on, which is my favorite quality in a liner. Just a touch or shimmer, but not overwhelming. They do not claim to be super long lasting, but since I have been using them, they stay put. Bottom line: I love them!
Colors (appear in swatch from left to right):
ali (dark gold)
ashlee (dark grey/silver)
katie (dark brown)
pics are my own