I finally checked out the store Five Below today! It has so many cheap items and I ended up finding a few cute beauty trinkets! Nail polishes were 3 for $5 and there was a tan silk headband for $2. The sparkly silver polish is called "Sand and Stilettos" by Funky Fingers, the dark teal is called "Spruce Street" by Fresh Paint and the peachy pink color is called "Papaya" by Fresh Paint. I've never heard of these brands before, but the colors are so pretty!
Photos are my own.