Photos belong to me, do not steal:!
I have been testing the Bobbi Brown gel liner and the MAC black track fluidline for a couple of weeks now! I was initially attracted to MAC's blacktrack via luuuxer HD (who is amazing I might add), and I was attracted to Bobbi Brown's liner through an older luuuxer name audrey ann. So in this blog I'll do a brief analysis of the pros and cons, ey?
1.) lasts nearly all day
2.) extremely pigmented
3.) can be worn alone
4.) beautiful packaging
5.) looks gorgeous on the waterline/tightline
1.) relatively dry compared to most gel liner formulas
MAC Black Track Fluidline:
1.) beautiful case
3.) great price
4.) easy application
1.) needs a powder to set it (once a powder sets it, it's good)
2.) smudges easier compared to the bobbi brown liner
Between the two, I think I'd wear the MAC blacktrack for more of a night look (since I tend to sweat less due to weather), and I'd wear the bobbi brown more for a throughout the day look. The bobbi brown formula lasts longer, but the MAC blacktrack is a lot easier to create winged tips etc. due to its creaminess.
This is just my personal opinion. If you don't have oily skin, you will love the MAC blacktrack a lot more then the bobbi brown liner. I love both, I think they both work for different types of weather for me. =) Just a personal opinion.